Your morning update from Salon.

Crash Course subscribers can join the conversation. Click the speech bubble to leave a comment. Tap the heart to leave a like.

CBS News is pushing out dissenters, replacing them with inexperienced hires. Read more.

The first word I’d use to describe Chat Pile is ugly. 

The Oklahoma noise rockers have a habit of pointing out the more grotesque aspects of American life. They took their band name from gravel hills of toxic mining waste  found across the Plains states, the sort of thing that would seem totally normal to a local and sickeningly absurd to an outsider. “God’s Country,” from 2022, is littered with observational tragedy, telling stories of beheadings at slaughterhouses and restaurant mass shootings over a relentless bed of creeping sludge.

“Why” sums up Chat Pile’s whole deal in a punishing three and a half minutes. Over stomping and sawing guitars and meat tenderizer drums, the band boils the homelessness crisis down to one simple question: “Why do people have to live outside?” As the band carries on like the proverbial orphan-crushing machine, vocalist Raygun Busch (get it?) shouts himself ragged wondering how the richest country in the world could leave hundreds of thousands of people out in the elements.

It’s a hard listen, even before Busch’s voice cracks on the line “I couldn’t survive on the streets.” It only gets harder when he starts questioning the listener directly, asking if they ever had ringworm or scabies. The wall of noise cuts out just once, when Busch notes that “we have the resources” to fix the problem. The grinding sound of his bandmates kicks right back up to let the listener know we aren’t there yet. “Why?” Busch screams. “Why?”

Plain-spoken lyricists tend to get short shrift when listmakers and music-raters start rattling off their all-time favorite songwriters. Taylor Swift’s QAnon-ian nested allusions and Bob Dylan’s surrealist ramble will always come out ahead for nerds because they give the listener a puzzle to figure out. There’s no room for Phil Elverum’s stark portrait of grief (“Death is real, someone’s there and then they’re not”) or Gene Simmons’ hopeful evening itinerary (“I wanna rock and roll all night”). But there’s something to be said for telling it like it is. 

You don’t have to take it from me, just take a look around. Donald Trump rode a successful message of locking up or deporting his enemies to the White House. Kamala Harris’ wonky grant programs couldn’t compete with the red meat Trump was tossing out at MAGA rallies. Zohran Mamdani successfully fended off a ratf**king by sticking to a message of free buses and universal daycare. 

Trump has remained remarkably transparent in office, laying his graft and corruption out for all to see as the GOP-built machinery chugs along to keep him from facing consequences. His press conferences are full of stark admissions of obvious self-dealing. Any private company he mentions by name is bound to get a government contract in the near term, just after Trump interests purchase their stock.

The plus side to this plain and apparent illegality should be obvious for Democrats. Assuming they can really take back power, they won’t don’t need to dig to find what the former administration did. The indictments will practically write themselves. The executive orders  and legislation should be written in advance, ready to go shortly after each new Trump outrage. 

Dems can put themselves in position to counter Trump 2 by following the president’s “keep it simple, stupid” example. Don’t talk about White House norms and constitutional arcana. State what the GOP did wrong without embellishment. The Republicans went all out to defend a con man who palled around with a pedophile. They stood aside as he stole taxpayer money and passed it on to rioters and sex criminals. They cheered as he involved the United States in a pointless, costly foreign war. If any Dem strategists are bashing their head against a wall trying to think of a campaign slogan that sums up the chaos and deprivation of Trump 2, Raygun Busch’s refrain is sitting right there: Why?

What do you think? Is the way to beat MAGA to out-simple them? Sound off in the comments.

Cultish devotion leads Republicans to see Trump as more god-like than human. Read more.

Spring Sale! Support Salon's bold journalism. Become a member for just $49.

At the Christian gathering in DC, the message to Muslims like me was clear. From my grave, I'll preach coexistence. Read more.

The professionals pulling ahead aren't working more. They're using Claude.

Our free guide will show you how to:

Transform your workflow with AI and stay ahead of the curve with this comprehensive guide to using Claude at work.

Get The Free Guide