The Constitution gets memory-holed

A recent glitch at the Library of Congress underlines the importance of holding on to physical media

Crash Course subscribers can join the conversation. Click the speech bubble icon to leave a comment or tap the heart to like this post.

The news, in brief …

  • Former Superman Dean Cain stumps for ICE hiring initiative

    The actor best known for playing Clark Kent pushed his followers to become immigration agents. Read more.

  • Ex-“Alligator Alcatraz” worker details “inhumane” treatment

    A former corrections officer said they were horrified by conditions at the Florida immigrant detention center. Read more.

  • Fired Labor commissioner should sue Trump for defamation

    Dr. Erika McEntarfer's public ouster is actionable because of Trump's false accusations. Read more.

  • “I thought people were going to die”: Anti-ICE protesters say they were attacked by police

    Supporters of detained chaplain Ayman Soliman say cops assaulted them at a recent protest, but they're not deterred. Read more.

  • Bondi’s phony Obama probe exposes Trump’s fears

    Even MAGA struggles to care about Trump's efforts to distract from his long friendship with Jeffrey Epstein. Read more.

  • Texas Dems to DC: “Do something — or get out of the way”

    Democrats who fled Texas to block a Republican gerrymander told Salon that national leaders need to step up next. Read more.

Make me smarter …

Getty Images

Trump is sending a dark signal with his White House expansion

Donald Trump's "White House Ballroom" is unlikely to be finished anytime soon. So who is it for? Read more.

Getty Images

A republic, if you can remember it

Unlike the Battles of Lexington and Concord, we do know who shot first at the Mos Eisley cantina.

In the original cut of “Star Wars,“ Harrison Ford gave audiences everything they needed to know about his character in the time it took to pull a trigger. Han Solo shooting bounty hunter Greedo under the table established him as a survivor who was charismatic and heroic, sure, but also impatient and impulsive. In a binary world defined by Jedi goodie-two-shoes and Sith baddies, Solo made a living in the grey areas.

At least, he used to. In re-releases of the seminal space opera, Greedo fires an errant shot from feet away before the smuggler fires back, as director George Lucas wanted to scrub the grime off of Solo’s character. It’s been a source of controversy among the “Star Wars” fandom ever since, though they’re far from alone in having to keep the original version alive in their memories.

Streaming services and re-releases in recent years have scrubbed all manner of material from movies and TV shows. Controversial gags have been removed from everything from “The Office” to the 2024 “Mean Girls” musical. Entire episodes of NBC’s “30 Rock” and FX’s “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia” have been memory-holed. Series that only saw release on streaming platforms become inaccessible once they’re removed from digital syndication.

The U.S. Constitution is a bit more serious than an episode of network TV that included depictions of blackface or the shotguns that officers held in “E.T.” And yet, a recent glitch at the Library of Congress is one more exhibit in a case that archivists and pop culture obsessives have been hammering for years: get yourself a physical copy of the media you care about.

According to the Library of Congress, a “coding error” caused several sections of Article I of the Constitution to disappear. The fact that the missing text included the right to challenge detention by authorities, at a time when President Donald Trump is pursuing an agenda of widespread arrests through Immigration and Customs Enforcement, raised more than a few eyebrows.

President Trump gave name to the era of alternative facts. He’s spent the last month trying to convince his followers that the case against Jeffrey Epstein, compiled on his watch, was a hoax perpetrated by Democratic politicians.

New technologies allowing easy deepfakes and edits to the record turn that tendency for fudging the facts when they’re inconvenient from comical to frightening. The U.S. Constitution is as unlikely to become lost media as a Gideon Bible. Still, a copy that can’t be modified, crudely with Sharpie or via a few backend alterations, is a necessity when those in power are so willing to lie about history.

What do you think? Do you believe the glitch explanation offered by the Library of Congress? Are people who remember their rights against illegal search and seizure going to be treated the same as true believers in the Sinbad movie “Shazam”? Sound off in the comments.

Support our bold journalism: Become a Salon member today.

Before you go …

Getty Images

Megyn Kelly’s Beyoncé meltdown has nothing to do with Sydney Sweeney

The singer's success seems to have deeply disturbed the right-wing podcaster. Read more.

ALSO FROM SALON
Standing Room OnlyAmanda Marcotte's biweekly politics newsletter for Salon readers who like to be plugged in and a little bit rowdy.

Reply

or to participate.